We’re currently preparing for one of the biggest production investments in Flexpress history: the installation of our new Ryobi 970 PF-8. It’s an impressive machine and will print both sides of a sheet simultaneously, dramatically increase our litho capacity, and give us significantly more production capability than we have today.
So, you might imagine that our biggest manufacturing question is: How quickly can we print?
But, increasingly, it isn’t. The more interesting question is: How quickly can we get a job all the way through the factory?
Whilst those two things sound similar, they’re actually very different because a printing press doesn’t manufacture a finished job.
Imagine a job that takes thirty minutes to print. On paper, making the printing press twice as fast sounds like a huge productivity improvement. But suppose that job then waits for two hours before it can be folded. Or sits overnight waiting for a perfect binder. Or needs a member of staff to manually move information from one system into another before the next process can begin.
Halving the printing time from thirty minutes to fifteen minutes has made almost no difference to the customer. Yes, the press has become more productive, but the factory hasn’t.
That distinction is one of the most important lessons we’ve learned about manufacturing.
Every factory has a constraint
One of the books that had a significant influence on my thinking is Eliyahu Goldratt’s The Goal.
At the heart of the book is a deceptively simple idea: every manufacturing system has a constraint.
Something, somewhere, ultimately determines how much the whole system can produce.
If your printing department can produce 100 jobs per day but your finishing department can only process 60, then your factory isn’t really capable of producing 100 finished jobs per day. It’s capable of producing 60.
The additional 40 simply become work in progress. They wait. And waiting is one of the least productive activities in any factory.
This sounds obvious when written down, but in reality, businesses can spend enormous sums improving parts of a process that aren’t actually restricting output:
- A machine becomes 20% faster.
- A department becomes more efficient.
- An operator shaves a few minutes from a task.
All worthwhile improvements perhaps, but if the real constraint is somewhere else, overall throughput may barely change. The bottleneck moves, and there’s another complication. If you successfully remove one bottleneck, another one appears!
That isn’t failure. It’s progress. For example: suppose finishing is limiting production and you double finishing capacity. Wonderful. But now printing might become the constraint. Increase printing capacity and next, perhaps guillotining becomes the problem. Solve that and it could become packing, or estimating, or administration. Or the speed at which customer artwork can be checked and approved.
The constraint simply moves.
For us, that has changed the way we think about investment. Rather than asking: “Which machine would we like to make faster?”, we increasingly ask: “What is preventing more completed work from leaving the factory?”
This produces some very different answers.
Why finishing matters so much
Printing naturally attracts attention. Printing presses are large, expensive and technically impressive, but commercially, finishing can be every bit as important. A beautifully printed sheet isn’t much use to a customer who ordered a finished booklet. This lesson has shaped a lot of our investment at Flexpress.
Several years ago, for example, we were heavily dependent on our Horizon Stitchliner for booklet production. It was a good machine and enormously important to the business; in fact, probably too important.
As volumes grew, we realised that relying on a single booklet-making line created both a capacity problem and a resilience problem, so we began looking for a second system. Initially, we considered buying used equipment.
The thinking was understandable: it was supposed to be the backup machine, but I was given some good advice. The prediction was essentially: if we added the capacity, we would probably end up using it – and that’s exactly what happened!
So, we bought a new Duplo system, and within around 18 months it had gone from being additional capacity to something we would struggle to operate without. It now runs extremely hard.
The experience taught us something important: that sometimes what looks like spare capacity today becomes tomorrow’s production requirement.
Capacity without flow can create a bigger problem
This is particularly relevant as we prepare for the Ryobi 970. The new press will give us substantially more litho capacity, which is fantastic. But if we simply celebrate the printing capacity and ignore everything that happens afterwards, we risk moving the queue from one place to another.
In fact, faster equipment can sometimes expose weaknesses elsewhere much more quickly.
Imagine opening a motorway from two lanes to six lanes, but leaving the exit road at one lane.
You haven’t necessarily solved congestion. You may simply have moved it.
Manufacturing works in much the same way. The objective, therefore, isn’t maximum utilisation of every individual machine. It is maximum useful flow through the entire system.
A machine standing still isn’t always a problem
This can feel counterintuitive because traditional manufacturing thinking often says that an expensive machine should always be running. After all, if you’ve paid for it, surely every idle minute is wasted?
Not necessarily. If a non-constrained machine produces more work than the next operation can handle, keeping it running simply creates more work in progress.
- More pallets.
- More storage.
- More handling.
- More scheduling complexity.
- More opportunity for jobs to be damaged, misplaced or delayed.
Sometimes the most efficient thing a machine can do is wait. What matters is not whether every machine is busy. What matters is whether the factory is producing the maximum number of completed jobs reliably.
Bottlenecks aren’t always machines
Another lesson we’ve learned is that the constraint isn’t necessarily physical equipment.
It can be a process. For example:
- artwork waiting to be checked
- an estimate waiting to be produced
- production information being entered twice
- somebody manually deciding which machine should run a job
- paperwork waiting to move between departments
- a customer query waiting for a response
- finished work waiting to be booked onto a carrier
None of those things appears on a machine specification sheet, yet any one of them can slow production. This is why manufacturing efficiency and automation are increasingly inseparable.
We have spent years looking for opportunities to remove unnecessary administration, reduce re-keying, automate routine decisions and connect different parts of our workflow; not because computers are inherently better than people. But because people are far more valuable when they are dealing with exceptions, solving problems and improving processes than when they are repeatedly transferring the same information from one place to another.
Resilience matters too
There is another dimension to efficiency that is easy to overlook: resilience. Theoretically, a factory with one machine running at 100% utilisation might look extraordinarily efficient. Until that machine breaks down - then output becomes zero.
For a trade printer, reliability matters enormously because our customers are often relying on us as part of their own supply chain. This means we have to think not only about capacity, but also about what happens when things go wrong.
- Where are we overly dependent on one piece of equipment?
- Where do we have alternative routes?
- Where would a breakdown immediately affect customers?
Sometimes investing in additional capacity isn’t about producing more. It’s about ensuring we can continue producing, and quite often, as we discovered with our second booklet-making line, the additional resilience eventually becomes additional productive capacity anyway.
What customers actually experience
Customers rarely care how many sheets per hour a printing press can produce – nor should they. What customers experience is much simpler:
- Did their job arrive when expected?
- Was the quality right?
- Was communication clear?
- Could we cope when they suddenly needed something urgently?
- Could we accommodate an unusually large order?
- Could they rely on us?
Those outcomes depend upon the whole manufacturing system. That is why our definition of efficiency has gradually changed. Efficiency isn’t simply: How quickly can we print this? It is:
How little unnecessary time can this job spend between entering our system and leaving the factory completed? And that includes printing. But it also includes estimating, artwork, scheduling, finishing, packing, dispatch, software, automation and people.
The modern print factory is a connected system
This is increasingly where modern print manufacturing is heading. The companies that succeed won’t necessarily be those owning the fastest individual machine. In fact, most modern equipment is already extremely productive.
The bigger opportunities increasingly exist between the machines:
- How quickly information moves
- How effectively jobs are scheduled
- How little manual intervention is needed
- How easily production can switch between alternative equipment
- How quickly problems become visible
- How effectively capacity is balanced
- And how little time a customer's job spends doing nothing
Our new Ryobi is going to make an enormous difference to Flexpress, but its real value won’t ultimately be measured by the number of sheets it can print in an hour. It will be measured by how effectively we integrate that capacity with everything around it, because the fastest machine in the factory isn’t always the answer.
The fastest factory is the one where the whole system works together.
← All articles in this issue